Best Pizza in Oakdale

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Oakdale, NY at 887 Montauk Hwy

Oakdale's Slice Since Day One

Order online

Pizza, Heroes & Italian Classics

Fresh pies, stacked heroes, and Italian dinners made to order on Montauk Highway.

Order Now

Pickup, Delivery, or Dine In

Call 631-589-5505 or order online anytime — pickup, delivery, or dine in.

Order Online

Pizza, Heroes, Pasta & More

We Cater. We Deliver.

Hot food trays for parties, events, and family gatherings. Call us to set up your order.

Book Catering

Oakdale's Neighborhood Pizzeria

La Supreme Pizza has been the go-to spot on Montauk Highway for fresh, made-to-order pizza, heroes, and Italian dinners. This is what a real neighborhood pizzeria looks like.

Great pizza place. Very fresh and the the guys were great. Gave me a soda with the slices. I will definitely be back if I’m in the area.

Ryan M.

Been a customer for 9 years, never had a bad meal. Pizza is always cooked the way I like (well done), Marinara & Alfredo sauces are great. Portions are perfect. The staff is always pleasant. Good job guys !!!

Tom G.

Great pizza very good lunch deal and great service

Gleb B.

Very, very good pizza. Big fan of the Crispino. The stuffed slice is amazing too excellent regular slices.

Steven H.

This parlor is nowhere near me but I make sure to go over the weekend. I love the crunch of the bottom & the softness of the top of the pizza. I almost always get a penne Vodka slice... Mmmm. I have told so many ppl about the amazing pizza here. Such a unique taste. I don't know how they do it but they do & I enjoy everything I've ever ordered from here

Jenn M.

La Supreme Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Join La Supreme Pizza Rewards

Catering

Let us cater your next event. Click below to get started.

Order catering

Frequently Asked Questions

What are you known for?

We are known for Gnocchi, Chicken Parmesan, Ravioli, Caprese, Garlic Bread, Mozzarella Sticks, Spaghetti, Margherita Pizza, Calamari, Tortellini, Garlic Knots, Antipasto Salad, Salads, Meat Pizza, Greek Salad, Cauliflower Crust Pizza, Pasta, Stuffed Pizza, Stromboli, Hawaiian Pizza, Penne Alla Vodka, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Fettuccine Alfredo, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Vegan Pizza, Cannoli, Caesar Salad, Lasagna, Sicilian Pizza, Tiramisu, Caprese Salad, Meatballs, Calzone, Wings, Cheesecake, Cheese Pizza, White Pizza, and Pizza

What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

Where are you located?

We are located in Oakdale, NY at 887 Montauk Hwy

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Islip, Oakdale, West Sayville, Sayville, Bohemia, Great River Station, Great River, North Great River, Bayport, East Islip, Islip Terrace, Holbrook, Ronkonkoma, Central Islip, Blue Point, Fire Island, Patchogue, Islandia, Fire Island Pines, and Cherry Grove.